KB Logo

TOLIS Group Knowledge Base

Browse KB by category:
Go to KB #:
Email   Bookmark

SAS versus Fibre Channel - Which do I choose?

Views: 18201
Votes: 1
Posted: 03 Jan, 2012

TOLIS Group currently offers tape storage bundles with two different interconnect options - Fibre Channel (FC) and Serial Attached SCSI (SAS). Many customers contact us because of confusion over which interface they should purchase. Aside from pricing differences (FC models average around $900 more than the same SAS model), there are other important infrastructure issues that must be considered.

Why should I choose a Fibre Channel solution?

If you are working in an environment where you already have an existing FC Fabric in place, choosing the FC option for our bundles is often the best solution. You can attach the FC library to your existing switched fabric, zone the library and a specified workstation for use in backup and archival operations and you’re ready to go. As mentioned there, the only thing that you must take into account is that a tape library does not work well with many possible controlling workstations in an open-zoned fabric. You must create a zone for the library and assign one specific workstation to that same zone. This workstation then becomes the system used to perform backup and archival operations.

On the other hand, if you don’t have an existing FC infrastructure, or you prefer a simpler connection with your workstations that is separate from your FC fabric, starting out with a FC-connected tape storage bundle is not a path that we recommend due to both the complexity and additional costs involved.

Why should I choose a SAS solution?

If you are working in a standalone or ethernet connected environment, a SAS bundle provides an easy to set up solution because once you have your SAS HBA installed in your workstation, SAS connectivity operates much like USB since most operating systems will support disconnecting and reconnecting a SAS tape solution in much the same manner as a USB mouse or keyboard. This makes a SAS bundle a plug and play solution for most situations. The only limitation to SAS connectivity is that you must have a host system that can support the addition of a PCIe HBA in an x4 or x8 (preferred) slot.

What about other connection types — iSCSI, Thunderbolt, USB, and Firewire ?

Thunderbolt solutions are available by using Thunderbolt to PCIe adapters like those from Sonnet Technology. This allows you to connect a SAS tape device to your Thunderbolt-enabled system through the use of a normal ATTO Technologies ExpressSAS HBA.

For the other types, aside from slower, much lower capacity devices such as DAT and aging AIT technologies, there are no tape solutions available for these alternate technologies.


For most users, SAS provides the best and easiest to use solution. However, if you currently have an existing FC fabric and the knowledge inherent with managing such an infrastructure, our FC bundles can be a great solution.

Others in this Category
document How Much Space Remains on a Tape?
document What are the proper settings for my tape drive or library and how does the BRU I/O buffer work?
document I think I found, or have found, a bug. How do I report this?
document How does BRU layout it's archives and catalogs on tape?
document 2:1 Compression is Not Real World and Most Never See 2:1 Compression
» More Articles

Powered by KnowledgebasePublisher
Page Load Time: 0.033431 seconds / 33.431 milliseconds.
Page File Size: 24740 bytes.